Riesling, Round.... uh.. 3, 4, and 5?

Yea ok, so this past weekend we decided to destroy our livers. If I start spewing out bile, well.. enjoy? Not like I'm going to stop this tasting... it's much too fun.

oh wait... forgot to post one of our last tastings.. soooo... back in May, we had Round 3 - St. Urbans Hof VS Louis Guntrum. Not much to say... tho that might be due to this
tasting being done a while ago. Senility may be hitting me sooner than expected. Anyhoo. St. Urbans Hof won that round, and from what I can remember, Louis Guntrum had a more... generic taste and it was less sweet.

Round 4 - Muller Catoir VS Selbach Riesling (this was also done a while back)
MULLER CATOIR, MULLER CATOIR, MULLER CATOIR, MULLER CATOIR. enuf said.

Round 5 - Willi Haag VS Dr. Pauly
Speaking for myself, I found these two wines very similar. Though Zarkotic found Dr. Pauly to be better than Willi Haag. SO - we took his judgment on this and dubbed Dr. Pauly to be the winner of this round.

Round 6 - Deinhard Piesporter VS Carrick
Another riesling for the double losses. Carrick was just as horrible as the Penfolds. As for the Deinhard, we had previously tried a Deinhard Piesporter in Oceana, leading
us to put this wine into the tournament. However, I think the one we got for the tasting is different than the one from the restaurant... shitty

Round 7 - Trimbach VS Robert Weil
* We're still in the middle of this round - to be continued

Riesling...FTW (updated)

Fuck, I was about to update my previous post (Riesling FTW.. Part 1) buuuut... fuck it. We have made so many adjustments that it just makes more sense creating a new post. Besides, it'll be nice to have a history/record of all the shit we've done (or thought about doing). OK, so here is the updated list of Rieslings we have decided to use for our tourney... I mean tasting.

(12) Dr. Loosen Riesling 2007
(3) Dienhard Piesporter (Still need to find the right one that we tried in Oceana)
(13) Muller Catoir 2007 Riesling Kabinett
(14) Dr. Pauly Bergweiler Riesling Spatlese 2002
(9) St. Urbans hof
(1) Donnhoff Riesling Kabinett 2006
(5) Schloss Lieser Riesling Kabinett 2006
(8) Robert Weil Riesling Kabinett Trocken 2007
(15) Markus Molitor Kabinett
(10) Wittmann Trocken 2007
(16) Trimbach Riesling Alsace 2002 (France)
(11) Willi Haag Riesling Spatlese 2007
(6) Carrick Riesling Central Otago (New Zealand) 2006 *LL*
(4) Penfolds Riesling Bin 202 (Penfolds Bin 51 2006 <-- alternate *LL*)
(2) Selbach - Oster Riesling Spatlese 2005
(7) Louis Guntrum

Note: *LL* are the Rieslings we have tried and have disliked. I mean.. we disliked it enough to not even have it compete against the other losers... as masochistic as we might seem to be, yea.. no. As for the ones that have no date; well, tough shit for us coz we were too oblivious to note the 
year and any other information that might have been useful at that time. 

And I have managed to fuck up the text wrapping on this thing..  Thank you